What does it mean to be Indian today? Specifically, what does it mean to be an Alabama-Coushatta Indian living on a reservation in East Texas, geographically far from ancestral territory and removed in time and by the intervention of white missionaries and government agents from the traditions and lifestyles of one's forebears?
All of the most emotional issues among contemporary Southeast Texas Native Americans—including repatriation of remains, educational funding, health care, and cultural preservation—in some way address the question of personal identity. Difficulties in determining who and what are "Indian" continually divide the community, and analyzing the Alabama-Coushatta cultural transition is complicated by the dearth of written sources and the repression by 1930 of most overt evidence of the old ways. In this book Jonathan Hook engagingly discovers the earlier cultural tradition and the influences that caused it to evolve to its present form and conceptualizes those changes in a way that explores the very concept of identity.
In vivid, efficient prose, Hook describes what is known of the various European intrusions into Creek (Muskhogean) culture and how these changed the tribal life of the Alabamas and Coushattas, eventually leading them to the reservation they now share in Southeast Texas. He draws on written sources where they are available but also on the oral history of tribal members, to whom he had unprecedented access. He describes village organization, leadership succession, the "law of retaliation," the jubilee celebration of the Green Corn Festival (when all crimes except murder were forgiven), the matri-clan social pattern and marriage practices, burial rites, and religious practices including pride in being "a peculiar and beloved people of God."
Hook then considers the dual paths of searching for cultural identity today: regenesis, "the reintroduction of cultural practices formerly observed by the group," and ethnogenesis, the creation of a new cultural identity through the deliberate introduction of cultural practices that were not part of a specific tribe's cultural heritage. Thus, he illustrates, on the Alabama-Coushatta reservation the attempt to recover Indian identity has meant the adoption of powwow and other pan-Indian expressions of art, music, attire, and religion. Largely it has meant the adoption of Plains Indians ways, however "foreign" those may be to the tribe's indigenous culture. For example, many Alabama-Coushatta dancers now dance the "grass" dance (of the Plains tribes) rather than the "stomp" dance (their own traditional ceremony). Hook explores this phenomenon nonjudgmentally, elucidating "the inherently mutable nature of ethnicity."
The result of Hook's work is a fascinating study of "the dynamic and contextually based nature of personal and communal ethnic identity." Five centuries of cultural transition are traced and assessed, yet still made to seem personal and very human. In his conclusion he symbolizes the analysis he has made as he describes a mixed-blood child dancing in a tribal ceremony. "This young child," he explains, "inherits a five hundred–year legacy of cultural transition instigated by Columbus's arrival in this hemisphere." The means of achieving continued ethnic survival, he concludes, is "learning to 'walk in both worlds.' . . . Both cultural worlds must be studied, understood, and navigated." This book is a beginning
What Readers Are Saying:
"Not only does Hook provide a basic history of the people, he also delves into one of the most important consequences of Indian contact with Euroamericans—the loss and recreation of culture."--David LaVere, University of North Carolina, Wilmington
"Not only does Hook provide a basic history of the people, he also delves into one of the most important consequences of Indian contact with Euroamericans—the loss and recreation of culture." --David LaVere, University of North Carolina, Wilmington
“This sturdily bound edition can be recommended to all public and academic libraries in Texas.” --Review of Texas Books
“. . . This book will reward those interested in the political personalities of the region—particularly Lyndon Johnson but also Lloyd Bentsen Jr. and the Kazens of Laredo—and will be especially helpful to readers seeking insights into the ways minority groups managed to acquire and wield political influence long before the civil rights revolution of the late 20th century.” --San Antonio Express News
“ . . . Hook, a Cherokee tribal member who lives near the Alabama-Coushattas, has made an important contribution to the scan literature about them. . . . his inclusion of the voices of the Alabama-Coushattas (and other Indians) makes this a worthy book for general and scholarly readers.” --Journal of Southern History
“Hook’s book is well-written and well-researched.” --Texas Books in Review
“ . . . The author . . . nevertheless is to commended for documenting the efforts of a group of people who have survived in the face of overwhelming odds.” --Journal of American History
“Hook’s study will be of interest and value to anthropologists, historians, and history enthusiasts alike. . . . a step in the right direction. . . . Skillfully written, The Alabama-Coushatta Indians sheds new light on an unfamiliar topic, and its thoughtful analysis encourages further study of a culture and history that have been neglected for too long.” --Alabama Review